I’ve tried Spenco and Superfeet and a few other brands. Orthotics are the only way to go, all other insoles are comparatively trash. I still have the last pair of Superfeet that I bought, they’re in my steel toe boots I only use when chopping wood. If I had to spend any real time walking in them I’d use proper orthos. Superfeert are incredibly inferior and they’re disposable. Grow up kids, invest in your feet, posture and knees. You only live once.